eGuide · free

Hiring a CFO, Step by Step

How to tell when you need a CFO, which kind, what to pay, and how to run a search that lands the right one.

Read the guideGet the PDF10 min read · For owners, CEOs and CFOs
CFO presenting to an owner and leadership team
5 typesof CFOs to choose from
1–2 wksto first interviews (typical)
1 yearretained guarantee

Do you need a CFO yet?

Many growing companies run well for years with a strong controller. These signs say it's time for a CFO.

  • You're raising capital, refinancing or working with a lender's covenants
  • The owner or CEO spends more time in the numbers than on the business
  • Your controller is at capacity and the close keeps slipping
  • Investors, a board or a buyer want forecasts, not just history
  • You're planning an acquisition, a recapitalization or an exit
ROARK tipNot ready for a full-time CFO? An interim or project CFO can lead a raise, a deal or a cleanup while you decide.

Choose the Kind of CFO You Need

CFOs aren't interchangeable. Name the job before you write the job description.

Scroll sideways to see the full table →

TypeWhat they're best atOften fits
StrategicGrowth plans, capital, investors and the boardPE-backed and fast-growing companies
OperationalCost, margin, systems and processManufacturers and distributors
Controller-plusAccurate, fast closes and audit-ready booksCompanies hiring their first CFO
DealDiligence, integration and exit readinessCompanies buying, selling or recapitalizing
TurnaroundCash, lenders and hard decisionsCompanies under financial pressure

Write a Scorecard, Not a Wish List

List the three to five results the CFO must deliver in the first 12 months. Then list the experience that proves someone can deliver them. Everything else is a nice-to-have.

  • Example result: close the books in 10 business days by month six
  • Example result: a 13-week cash forecast the bank trusts
  • Example result: ERP selection and go-live within budget

Set the Pay Range

Price the role before you talk to anyone. A range that's too low costs you months. Use the free ROARK Salary Guide for your city and company size, and plan for bonus and, often, equity or a long-term incentive.

Run the Search

  • Needs assessment: agree on the scorecard, pay, timing and must-haves
  • Market map: who has done this job, in your industry and size
  • Screen against the scorecard, not the résumé
  • Structured interviews with the same questions for every finalist
  • A short work sample, such as a review of last year's financials
  • References from a boss, a peer and someone who reported to them
  • Offer, resignation support and a start date

Questions to Ask in the Interview

  • Walk me through the first 90 days at your last company. What did you change first, and why?
  • Tell me about a forecast you got wrong. What happened next?
  • How have you worked with an owner who knows the numbers better than anyone?
  • What does a good month-end close look like, and how did you get there?
  • Which systems have you implemented, and what would you do differently?

Set Your New CFO up to Win

Share the scorecard on day one, schedule weekly time together for the first 90 days, and introduce them to your bank, CPA and key customers early. See our guide for leaders on the first 90 days for the other side of the table.

Take it with you

Get “Hiring a CFO, Step by Step” as a PDF

We'll email it to you, along with the ROARK Salary Guide.