CHOOSING A FIRM

ROARK vs. Other Options for Hiring a Leader

A staffing agency, a generalist recruiter, a large search firm or your own team can all fill a role. Here's an honest look at when each one fits, and where ROARK does its best work.

Business leaders comparing options
The challenge

Choosing the Wrong Path Costs More than the Fee

  • A bad hire is expensive. A mis-hire in a key seat costs time, money and team morale.
  • Not every firm fits every role. Volume staffing and leadership search are different businesses.
  • The cheapest option isn't always cheaper. Your own team's time and a long vacancy have real costs.
  • Promises are hard to compare. Guarantees, fees and processes vary widely.

It's hard to know which option is right when every firm says it's the best. You deserve a clear, honest comparison before you decide.

Leaders discussing a decision
How ROARK helps

We Specialize, so We Can Be Honest About Fit

We understand you're weighing cost, speed and risk, often with a seat already empty.

  • Focused on finance, accounting, HR and operations leaders
  • Permanent, interim, project and M&A support from one partner
  • A senior Client Success Partner on every search
  • Guarantees of up to 1 year on Retained and Executive Search
Side-by-side

Your Options for Filling a Leadership Seat

Scroll sideways to see the full table →

What to compareHiring on your ownStaffing agencyGeneralist recruiterLarge search firmROARK
Typical focusYour own network, job boards and HR teamHigh-volume and hourly roles across many functionsMany roles and industriesC-suite, often for large companiesFinance, accounting, HR and operations leaders for $20M to $1B+ companies
How it usually startsA job postingA job orderA job descriptionA retained search kickoffThe ROARK Needs Assessment of the business, role and culture
Solutions offeredPermanent hireMostly temporary staff, some permanentMostly permanent placementRetained executive searchPermanent search, interim leaders, project consulting and M&A support
Who you work withYour teamOften an account manager and a separate recruiterVariesOften a partner who sells and a team who searchesA senior Client Success Partner who leads the search
CostLowest direct cost; the most of your team's timeHourly markup or placement feeUsually a contingent feeRetainer, often paid regardless of outcomeRetained, Executive Search, Premium Search or Fast Fill; consulting billed for time
GuaranteeNoneVariesOften shortVaries1 year on Retained and Executive Search; 6 months Premium Search; 90 days Fast Fill
Often the best fit when…You have time, a strong network and a role that's easy to fillYou need volume or short-term coverage below the leadership levelThe role is common and the market is deepYou're hiring a CEO at a large companyThe role is a key leader in finance, accounting, HR or operations, or you need someone in the seat while you decide
General descriptions of typical approaches; individual firms vary. ROARK terms are set in each agreement.
When another option may be the better choice

We'd Rather You Choose Well than Choose Us

Hire on your own

If you hire the same roles often and know them well, with a strong network and time to run a process, your own team may be all you need. For senior leaders you hire only every few years, it helps to work with a team that recruits higher-level management every day.

Use a staffing agency

When speed and volume matter more than specialization, such as hourly or entry-level roles rather than high-impact positions, a staffing agency is built for that.

Use a large search firm

For a CEO search at a very large or public company, a global firm's reach can make sense.

Bring in ROARK

A boutique, specialized firm with white-glove service and people who care about the outcome. When the seat is a key finance, accounting, HR or operations leader, or you need someone in place while you decide, that's where we focus.

Before you decide

Questions Worth Asking Any Firm

Use our free checklist, tailored to your industry, ownership and stage, to compare firms side by side.

The plan

Three Simple Steps

1Book a meetingA free discovery conversation about your challenge, the seat and the timing.
2Get the right solutionA permanent search, an interim leader, a project consultant or a combination, recommended for your situation.
3Grow with confidenceThe right leader in the seat, backed by our guarantee and regular check-ins.
What's at stake

Without the Right Leaders

  • A long vacancy that slows the business
  • A rushed hire you regret
  • Fees paid for the wrong kind of search
  • A team stretched too thin

With the Right Leaders

  • The right path for this role
  • A leader who fits your business
  • Clear terms and a guarantee
  • Time to focus on running the company
Frequently asked questions

Comparison Questions

Is ROARK a staffing agency?

No. We focus on finance, accounting, HR and operations leaders, through permanent search, interim leaders and project consulting.

Is ROARK more expensive than doing it ourselves?

The direct cost is higher, but so is the cost of a long vacancy or a mis-hire. We're happy to talk through whether outside help makes sense for your role.

Can we use ROARK alongside another firm?

Executive Search includes three months of exclusivity and Premium Search two months; Fast Fill requires none.

Not sure which option fits your role?

Book a meeting and we'll give you an honest recommendation.